Image may be subject to copyright

The Best Restaurants in Monticello, Indiana

Name: Lighthouse Lodge B&B on Lake Shafer
Address: 4866 N Boxman Place, Monticello, Indiana, 47960, US
Telephone: 574-583-9142

Monticello is the dream destination for your vacation not only because of its convenient location and fun natural and man-made attractions, but also because of the food you can snack on throughout the day. Whether you choose to grab a burger or order a pizza for the group, there are scrumptious options available.

The Whistle Stop

Address: 10012 US-421, Monon
Hours:
Tuesday - Thursday: 11AM - 8PM
Friday - Saturday: 11AM - 9PM
Sunday: 11AM - 7PM
Closed Mondays

Perhaps the fanciest option in Monticello, the Whistle Stop is a classic American restaurant that doubles as a train museum. You'll be able to eat a fine cut of steak after you've toured the exhibits. Place your reservation now! It's a must-see eatery.

The Whistle Stop Menu

Filet Mignon
Rib Eye
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Fresh Lake Perch
Jumbo Breaded Shrimp
Potato Chip Crusted Pork Chop or Chicken Breast
Grilled Tenderloin

MORE INFO

Sportsman Inn

Address: 12340 N Upper Lakeshore Dr #4749, Monticello
Hours:
Monday - Tuesday, Thursday - Sunday: 11AM - 12AM
Closed Wednesdays

The Sportsman Grill has a few different cuisines you can enjoy. Grab a bite of pasta, some BBQ ribs, a classic steak, or grilled buffalo wings. Yum yum!

Sportsman Inn Menu

Loaded Fries
Boneless Wings
Nacho Supreme
Firecracker Shrimp
Tenderloin Bites

MORE INFO

Riverside Restaurant

Address: 1809 N Francis St, Monticello
Hours:
Monday - Thursday: 4PM - 9PM
Friday - Saturday: 4PM - 10PM
Sunday: 11AM - 9PM

Those looking for a fun, social restaurant will want to turn up at the Riverside Restaurant. Not only are the food options straightforward and easy to eat (keeping silence during your meals brief), but there is usually live music playing in the background. This is a 10/10 restaurant.

Riverside Restaurant Menu

Broiled Stuffed Shrimp
Fresh Catfish
Salmon Caesar Salad
Elk Burger
Killer Tenderloin
Chicken Sandwich

MORE INFO

Jimmy O's Bar & Grille

Address: 5658 NW Shafer Dr, Monticello
Hours:
Monday - Friday: 11AM - 2AM
Saturday and Sunday: 8AM - 2AM

Jimmy O's is renowned for its pizza. Because of this, it's a great place to eat if you are with a lot of family and friends. Select from a wide range of toppings. If pizza isn't your thing, there are a few lighter options like salads and fish and chips.

Jimmy O's Menu

Fish and Chips
Steak Salad
Gourmet Pizzas

MORE INFO

Anglers Restaurant

Address: 1828 N Francis St, Monticello
Hours:
Tuesday - Saturday: 4PM - 9PM
Sunday: 12PM - 8PM
Closed Mondays

Despite the name, you won't find much seafood at the Anglers Restaurant. Instead, you'll find plenty of poultry and pork as a suitable replacement. Perfect for a lunchtime meal.

Anglers Restaurant Menu

Smothered Chicken
Black N Blue Salad
Chicken Parmesan Alfredo
Pork Tenderloin

MORE INFO

El Lago

Address: 5313 NW Shafer Dr, Monticello
Hours:
Sunday, Wednesday, and Thursday: 11:30AM - 8:30PM
Friday - Saturday: 11:30AM - 9PM
Closed Mondays and Tuesdays

A classy Mexican restaurant with a ton of personality, El Lago should be a part of your vacation itinerary. You'll want to be a part of this fiesta!

El Lago Menu

Marinated Steak Fajitas
El Lago Nachos
Crispy Fish Tacos
Filet Mignon Burrito.

MORE INFO

Arni's Pizza

Address: 517 N Main St, Monticello
Hours:
Sunday - Thursday: 11AM - 9PM
Friday and Saturday: 11AM - 9:30PM

While East-Coast residents may be familiar with Arni's Pizza, travelers from elsewhere will be in for a nice surprise. Check out the Italian delicacies before you leave town. There are also American foods as well.

Arni's Menu

Mozzarella Sticks
Loaded Cheese Fries
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Killer Cajun Pizza
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich

MORE INFO

Cazadores Mexican Restaurant

Address: 111 N Main St, Monticello
Hours:
Monday, Wednesday - Thursday: 11AM - 8PM
Friday - Saturday: 11AM - 9PM
Closed Sundays and Tuesdays

This Mexican place is a great lunch stop for your future vacation. Not only does it have all the staples Americans know and love, but it also serves Tex-Mex bowls, which blend two delightful cuisines into one tightly-packed dish.

Cazadores Mexican Restaurant Menu

Tex-Mex Bowls
Chimichangas
Burritos
Enchiladas

MORE INFO